Last week | Weaver's Week Index | Next week
Last month, we looked at 99 to Beat and found that its winner won their prize through being lucky, more than any other individual skill. We promised to take a look at the Dutch original series, and see what skills are tested there. And we're going to deliver on our promises.
For this exercise, we're watching series 3, which first aired on commercial channel SBS at the start of 2022. It was filmed during the previous autumn, and each episode begins with a small notice that it was filmed with regard to the health situation at the time.
Prize for the series is € 50.000, described as "one year free" – it's somewhat more than the average pre-tax wage.
Voiceover for the show is Frank Lammers: clear and relatively friendly, with good intonation of his voice. He also does commentary on the games – no need for a separate Pat 'n' Pete, The Voice does it all.
As we did for the ITV version, we'll briefly describe each game, then put it into one of eight categories: social, scares, physical, dexterity, co-ordination, memory, mental, fortune. We might have a few other notes, but won't list the number of appearances the contestant made.
| Game | Description | Category | Notes |
| 100 | Catch a velcro ball on each of two oversized hands | Dexterity | |
| 99 | Cook popcorn from kernels, foil, matches, and tealights | Mental | Seemed to be a lot of contestants looking at what others did |
| 98 | Make a freestanding tower from plastic straws at least 1,70m tall | Co-ordination | Marshals had sticks 1,70m long |
| 97 | Stand on a yoga block on one leg; first to touch the floor loses | Dexterity | |
| 96 | Add up the numbers on dogs that go through an obstacle course | Mental | |
| 95 | Musical chairs | Physical | Can the last contestants run in the right direction? |
| 94 | How many peas in the jar | Mental | Similar to the game on ITV |
| 93 | Find the flag with your name on it | Fortune | |
| 92 | Balance an egg on the underside of a pan, walk it a few metres, tip it into a glass | Dexterity | First of a number of games that were split into two groups, last player in each group went through to a superfinal. |
| 91 | Algebra puzzle: pop a balloon with an incorrect answer | Mental | 91 different balloons with 91 different answers |
When first broadcast in 2022, the opening episode was a double-length episode, which we found a slog. Everything else was 41 minutes of action in a commercial hour – when we take out the chatter, about as much as ITV gives us.
| Game | Description | Category | Notes |
| 90 | Throw balls to knock over a pyramid of tin cans | Co-ordination | Another two groups and superfinal game. |
| 89 | Calculation game: worst answer to three questions goes to superfinal | Mental | |
| 88 | Catch a red feather in a butterfly net | Co-ordination | We saw this on ITV much later in the series. |
| 87 | Flip a slipper as far as possible | Co-ordination | Flip-off between the two whose slipper went backwards. |
| 86 | Flip a bottle so it lands flat | Co-ordination | Played on ITV with traffic cones, a much harder variant. |
| 85 | Phones out: first to ring loses | Fortune | Took over 20 minutes for anyone to call someone. |
| 84 | Cut 64 perfect cucumber circles | Dexterity | About a dozen needed a second cucumber and had the target reduced to 50 in total. ITV played a similar challenge with onions. |
| 83 | Fire a shuttlecock over the net | Co-ordination | First one-by-one challenge |
| 82 | Total weight of a garden gnome, 56 pancakes, a vase of flowers, an ornate chair, and the model demonstrating them | Mental | |
| 81 | Teams: float a ball up a tube by moving water in tiny buckets | Dexterity | Whittle from teams of 27 to 9 to 3 to 1. The cups and tube got smaller and smaller each time, and – yes – the solo players had to move water from one teeny cup to another. |
For game 89, the questions were:
How long is the Great Wall of China (21 196km);
What is the world record for the longest fingernails on one hand (909,6cm);
What was the total market value of the Dutch team in Euro 2020? (€¬ 637mn).
Furthest from each answer was asked for the total age of the 89 remaining candidates (3163; just like on ITV, there were a lot of twentysomethings).
| Game | Description | Category | Notes |
| 80 | Pairs game: hold spaghetti in your mouths, pass it through the ringpull of a can, then move it a few metres and set it down on a table. | Social | Players get to pick their own pairs. Each of the last two from both groups picks a safe player to help in the final. |
| 79 | After hearing a story, give the meanings of certain dialect words | Memory | Story read by the famous actor Pieter Embrechts, the local equivalent of Justin Edwards. |
| 78 | One by one, re-stack the bottom from a tower of plastic cups to the top until the golden cup emerges | Dexterity | |
| 77 | Solve the yellow face of a 2x2x2 Rubik's cube | Mental | |
| 76 | Beerpong | Co-ordination | Played with water and no drinking. Two groups, the final was first to make a line of three on a 3x3 grid. |
| 75 | Link groups with elastic bands, then shake and manoeuvre to get a hula hoop from one end to the other | Dexterity | Whittle: 3 groups of 25, then 5 of 5, then 5 solo players |
| 74 | Get a euro coin out of a piggybank with only a paperclip | Co-ordination | As seen on ITV. |
| 73 | Curl up a slinkie on the forehead | Dexterity | Once the slinkie's in place, it must stay there. Dutch for "slinkie" is "olifantslurf". |
| 72 | Bounce a pencil into a pot | Dexterity | Third straight game we saw on ITV. |
| 71 | Rebuses on five different delivery tuktuks that pass before your eyes, solve them to make a sensible phrase | Mental | |
For this series, all pieces to camera are done in the arena, which is a large sportshall with some natural light from the windows. There are no cutaways to just outside, as we saw on ITV.
| Game | Description | Category | Notes |
| 70 | Throw a cardboard box so it lands on another cardboard box | Co-ordination | Boxes are cubes about 1m across, spaced about 2m apart. |
| 69 | Pack sticky tape in a lunchbox | Dexterity | Another one we saw on ITV. |
| 68 | Basketball in pairs: one to throw, one to catch in a hoop around the waist | Co-ordination | Pick your own partner; last pair pick from safe players. |
| 67 | Remember and reproduce a sequence of 15 colours | Memory | First error loses |
| 66 | Make and throw a paper aeroplane through a cardboard hoop of fire | Co-ordination | |
| 65 | Observation quiz about drag queens' costumes | Memory | Runaround style, last to get one right loses |
| 64 | Count the dimples on a golf ball | Mental | |
| 63 | Float a tower of five cans in a bowl of water | Dexterity | |
| 62 | Music quiz: is it a Dutch song or an international cover? | Memory | Wave a flag for a Dutch song, a suitcase for a cover. |
| 61 | Extend a tape measure then retract it to pick up a pencil | Co-ordination | ITV had a simpler and fussier version |
They don't particularly care for continuity, contestants change outfits part-way through an episode.
| Game | Description | Category | Notes |
| 60 | Twerk to transfer a cd along a coiled rope | Physical | Pairs game, worst couple pick a partner |
| 59 | Kick a football over a washing line and into a basket you can't see | Fortune | Four groups, worst in each play again |
| 58 | Float a ball out of a bottle using milk from a coconut | Physical | Hardest part seemed to be opening the coconuts |
| 57 | Drink exactly 1 litre from a 1,5 litre bottle while blindfolded | Physical | Player who emptied her bottle lost |
| 56 | Quiz on pets and animal | Memory | Runaround style again, last to get one right loses |
| 55 | Kicks from the penalty mark against an undefended goal | Co-ordination | Loser goes on to manage England (sub: please check) |
| 54 | Pairs: wind 25m of rope from one to the other | Physical | Variant seen on ITV |
| 53 | Remove tools and nuts on a long metal rod | Dexterity | |
| 52 | Pick up and carry plastic cutlery in a washing-up bowl | Dexterity | |
| 51 | Dirty cash: two volunteers step forward, by chance one leaves with money, other stays in the game and gets gunged | Social | Dutch auction of rising money – one player took € 550. |
In this episode, they made a claim that does not stand up to scrutiny. "Average Dutch household has three pets" factoid actualy just statistical error. Average Dutch household has zero pets. Huisdieren Henrik, who lives on a hill in Flevoland and has 24 million pet fleas, is an outlier adn should not have been counted.
| Game | Description | Category | Notes |
| 50 | Knock a football along a course, using a tennis ball in a stocking hanging from your head | Co-ordination | Variant on ITV. Five heats of ten, worst played again, and perhaps cut too short. |
| 49 | Break down cardboard boxes to fit into one box | Physical | |
| 48 | Plant a painted egg in a detailed scene, first egg to be found is out | Fortune | |
| 47 | Roll a ping-pong ball on a slanted table so it lands in a net | Dexterity | |
| 46 | Get over a hurdle some distance away while blindfolded | Dexterity | Ends up as a test of direction |
| 45 | Use a balloon to move plastic cups from one table to another | Dexterity | |
| 44 | Assemble a stepladder from flat-pack furniture and no instructions | Mental | |
| 43 | Drop a coin into a glass in a tank of water | Co-ordination | |
| 42 | Quiz about animal noises: is it an animal or not? | Mental | As they say in Dutch: Dier of no dier |
| 41 | Make a chain of sausage balloons to stretch 10m | Mental | Players are provided with inflating pumps, it's not a test of lung capacity. Loser looped his balloons around like a chain, everyone else tied them end to end. |
Number estimation challenges tend to pick three people out – one is very low, one is very high, one is spot on. Adds to the tension, especially amongst contestants who will have chatted while their numbers are marked. And for the viewer, it's an extra moment of tension.
| Game | Description | Category | Notes |
| 40 | Hammer a nail into a plank to hang a picture – while wearing boxing gloves | Dexterity | |
| 39 | Make your way through a maze while blindfolded | Mental | |
| 38 | Duos: throw and catch a rabbit in the hole in a top hat | Co-ordination | Worst pair pick new partners |
| 37 | Knock down three pens so they remain beneath the lip of a bottle | Co-ordination | |
| 36 | Put a loose chain back on a bike, then ride it 20m | Memory | All about knowing the technique |
| 35 | Sharpen pencils to red and blue halves | Physical | Another ITV game |
| 34 | Throw a reel of toilet roll over a bar, then stretch it back to tie on a rope | Dexterity | Two heats, losers play again |
| 33 | Stack about twenty tin cans into one pile | Dexterity | Went to video review, decided by about half a second. |
| 32 | Volleyball whittle | Physical | As seen on ITV. |
| 31 | Clear lengths of marking tape off the floor | Physical |
Every episode begins with the same spiel: "Best candidates, you are now 94 – but not for much longer! The next game is simple..."
The circle of players remains even through the show, just further spaced out. There's none of the stand on a specific spot and have your light turn red as we saw on ITV.
| Game | Description | Category | Notes |
| 30 | You're given a right slipper; find its pair in a large ball pool | Fortune | Poor television; grown people scrabbling for something they – and we – cannot see |
| 29 | Logoquiz: see 15 logos for a few seconds, say what they're for | Memory | A pen and paper quiz, play along at home. Seemed to be bad for the older players. [This column got 9/15] |
| 28 | Hold a hook on a chain in your mouth, use it to life a crab out of an aquarium filled with water | Dexterity | Arguably scares, as players are expected to dunk their faces below water |
| 27 | Cycle along a narrow path to ring a bell – and don't fall off! | Co-ordination | One-by-one challenge, with a Hotseat for the worst performer so far |
| 26 | Questions about the nineties; popular Dutch culture | Mental | With deejay Paul Elstak, later the writer and producer of "Europapa". Remember, many contestants weren't even born in the 90s. |
| 25 | Hook a duck – must be yellow, no other colour is good | Co-ordination | Guttering arranged in a square, ducks float round |
| 24 | Pull a string using your mouth to get a point close enough to pop a balloon | Physical | Test is mostly getting 3m of string into your mouth |
| 23 | Sort red, white, and blue pins from a pinboard to make the Dutch flag | Mental | |
| 22 | Work in pairs to move magnetic letters and spell "ALLESKUNNER"; one can see, one is beneath the table with a magnet | Social | Totally a test of communication |
| 21 | Two large plastic water containers make an eggtimer, with balls inside. Shake the containers so all the balls fall down | Physical |
Music choices are very on point, appropriate for the leaving contestant, and used during the contest to set the mood. Possibly a little less predictable than ITV's picks, but not by much.
| Game | Description | Category | Notes |
| 20 | Lick a window with your tongue, and follow the instructions on it | Physical | Done while blindfolded; candidate chose to remove their blindfold rather than throw up. Don't expect to see this on ITV. |
| 19 | Scoop a plastic fish out of a paddling pool and drop it into an aquarium. Do this while wearing glasses to turn the world upside down | Co-ordination | Again, this could class as "scares". |
| 18 | Hold a spoon with an egg on in your mouth while a comedian tells jokes. First to laugh loses. | Dexterity | Star guest tells jokes for about 40 seconds. |
| 17 | Spelling bee | Memory | Played while other candidates enjoyed a silent disco. |
| 16 | Pass a water balloon down your team: last person throws at a plastic flamingo, and team to knock it off is safe | Co-ordination | Whittle with teams of 8, 4, 2, 1. |
| 15 | Untangle 15m of extension cables | Mental | |
| 14 | Make wind with a little plastic fan to propel a sailboat down some guttering | Physical | |
| 13 | Roll a marble down a narrow path; one that goes least far is out | Co-ordination | |
| 12 | Pour cups of water to fill a tube; stick matches into the holes in the tube otherwise all the water will drain out | Mental | You don't need to plug all the gaps, just enough to keep the ball rising |
| 11 | Which family member goes with which of the 11 remaining candidates? | Memory | This gets a very long edit – almost 7 minutes |
A lot of contestants came in couples. First ep introduced us to Rosé and Dick, The Married Couple; and to Michen and Dion, The Twins; both of those had one contestant make the later shows. Second half of that episode brought us Sonja and Nick, mother and son; and Maartje and Rosa, The Younger Couple, but they were introduced only to be split up.
Pieces to camera are very short – rarely more than a sentence. It's difficult to get to know anyone until much later in the series, when we've seen them a lot. Only the last two contenders get any sort of serious pieces to camera.
| Game | Description | Category | Notes |
| 10 | Navigate a course from memory, without knocking over china, while blindfolded | Physical | First to knock over some china loses; very unlikely that all ten would finish |
| 9 | "Who am I?" – ask yes/no questions about a name on your forehead | Memory | After forty minutes of play, with the three remaining contestants stuck, a hint – first two letters of the forename |
| 8 | Stack eight hexagonal nuts on top of each other (edge to edge) using chopsticks | Dexterity | |
| 7 | Drive a radio-controlled car through a course | Co-ordination | Very Crystal Maze. |
| 6 | Balance a ball on a plate atop a long thin pole, carry it across the hall to a magnet dangling from the ceiling | Dexterity | |
| 5 | All candidates throw at a dart board showing everyone's face. First candidate with five darts in their sector is out. | Social | Actively seeking to eliminate someone? Ouch! |
| 4 | Bring blocks to a tilting table while holding a rope keeping the table flat | Co-ordination | When a block falls, must drop any you're carrying and correct it. Think they had something similar on Crystal Maze and nobody won it. |
| 3 | Stop the clock at precisely 3 minutes | Mental | |
| 2 | Set wooden blocks on a large tower that leans with the added weight. Any that fall on your turn are added to your pile; first player to place all their blocks wins. | Dexterity | Place blocks on levels according to dice rolls. |
| 1 | Wins € 50.000 | All of the eliminated contestants invited back to see the final. | |
So let's crunch the numbers.
| Category | Count |
| Social | 4 |
| Scares | 0 |
| Physical | 14 |
| Dexterity | 24 |
| Co-ordination | 24 |
| Memory | 10 |
| Mental | 17 |
| Fortune | 5 |
That does feel more balanced than ITV's 99 to Beat: fortune plays a role, but it's not the main determinant of who wins the show. We're comfortable with about half the show being in the dexterity and co-ordination space, and the problem-solving tasks – where there are often a lot of possible ways to complete – are particularly entertaining. A quiz most weeks – but not every week – seems enough.
For comparison, 13 of the 99 challenges were also used on 99 to Beat. That leaves us with 185 distinct little mini-games from these series – and we've not examined four other Dutch series, or the celebrity spin-offs, or the German show.....
As a television entertainment, De Alleskunner works for the Dutch market: it's fast, it's skilfully edited, and if you don't like one challenge there will be another along in a moment. Every elimination is earned, absolutely nobody leaves through someone else's fault.
Had they tried to replicate De Alleskunner in this precise format on ITV, it would surely have sunk without trace. ITV were right to concentrate on some characters, bring out the human relationships between the players – whether established before going into the show, or found during the recording process. Because we heard something about the players' lives, we could empathise more with them. And because we were left to remember about 25 people from one week to the next, they gave us reason to care, some of the people we liked this week have survived and we are interested to see how they get on.
That's not to say ITV got everything right: we still think there were far too many team challenges where everyone left, too many people got into the second half of the series without talking to us, and it's simply bizarre not to hear from the winner at all until the semi-final. But even amongst the early departures, the ITV show built firm narratives about the people playing; De Alleskunner never really spoke to life outside the playing arena. De Alleskunner was wholly about the challenges, 99 to Beat was also about the people, and we respect the difference.
We hear that Fox Television (a wholly-owned subsidiary of the Rupert Murdoch media empire) has made a version of 99 to Beat, and increased its prize to USD 1 million (after taxes, about € 535.000, £464,000). It's been made at the same location – and possibly using some of the same challenges – as ITV's programme.
The BBC has decided what to do with those Masterchef Goes Large episodes featuring the sex pest and the foul mouth. The episodes will go out on BBC1, and may be re-edited to reduce the amount of time the disgraced hosts are on screen.
David Ford was the winner on Mastermind; he trailed after his specialist round on LS Lowry, but knocked out a superb general knowledge score of 16 – it'll be one of the highest of the heats. Dennis Wang scored thirteen on the men's Euros, but a few flubs in the second round cost him the victory. Another contestant took Gilmore Girls, and this column's proud to have got four right, so half the contender's score. And we wonder how Nemo is getting on with their unbreakable Eurovision prize of Gilmore Girls series three, the best series.
Whitley Baes took the opening victory on Only Connect, beating the Caraxians (fans of Leos Carax, the film director). Best get was at the start of the show, picking up the link "Rocket" from a snooker player and a furry raccoon. Sad to see the walls proving the great leveller, as in both teams failing to make a single connection, we think for the first time in 21 series.
A frantic University Challenge saw UCL beat SOAS by 210-170. Right from the first buzz (a penalty), UCL were never headed, though their neighbours always kept very close. The chaotic final minutes had all sorts of fouls: two contestants answering simultaneously, a penalty assessed but not announced, and starters dropped like cabbages.
UCL's overall accuracy of 64% is as good as last year's side; the bonus rate of 77% matched last year's squad's top performance which was the highest of the last series. And it's not even the highest bonus conversion rate of the night, because SOAS struck 79% on their bonuses. We expect to see both sides again.
We managed to miss The Traitors Prom (Radio 3, yesterday). Apparently we're to come for Claudia Winkleman, stay for Linda earning her Gielgud Award nomination, and Alexander auditioning to be the new Petroc Trelawney.
They've trailed it for months, and finally BBC1 gets around to showing Destination X (Wed and Thu). Where has Rob Brydon led his guests this time? Speaking of great things from Wales, there's a celebrity edition of Am Dro! around Wrexham (S4C, Thu).
We find the winners of Bake Off The Professionals (C4, Tue), and Game On, Grandparents! (CBBC, Thu). New episode of Dragons' Den (BBC1, Thu) and The Bidding Room (BBC1, from Mon). Pointless marks its 2000th edition with an all-star celebrity edition: Shaun Williamson, Steve Pemberton, Charlie Higson, and Cariad Lloyd are all in the same room.
For various reasons, we're taking an unusual publishing schedule, so watch out for the return of Cooking With the Stars (ITV, Sunday 3 August) and The Fortune Hotel (ITV, Wednesday 6 August). Masterchef Goes Large has also crept back on the schedules (BBC1, from Wednesday 6 August). We'll be back on or about 8 August, with something of a European travel theme.
To have Weaver's Week emailed to you on publication day, receive our exclusive TV roundup of the game shows in the week ahead, and chat to other ukgameshows.com readers, sign up to our Google Group.